17 Best Metal Detectors in 2018 - Metal Detector Reviews & Ratings
93

What is the best metal detector?

You’d like to get into metal detecting but aren’t sure which detector to go with.

You’ve searched high and low on all the detecting forums, and read countless opinions, reviews and case studies - most of them likely biased.

Your Youtube homepage is littered with ‘Recently Watched’ videos of every type of detector review and unboxing.

Does this sound like you?

If so, then this article is for you. I’m going to go into detail on the best metal detectors and explain what to look for when choosing.

But first, some hard truth.

There is no universal “best” metal detector.

The question you should be asking is, “what is the best metal detector for the type of hunting I want to do, where I live, my experience, and my budget.”

To answer that question, there are a few factors which may or may not affect your decision-making process.

The purpose of this article is to break everything down in real terms, so you have a much better idea of which detector is best for YOU!

Summary

Here are the best metal detectors of 2018

Updated: June 2018



Skill Level

First and foremost, let’s talk about your experience metal detecting.

Have you ever detected before?

If yes, you skip this section and move on.

If no, then you’re probably going to want to start with an entry-level machine. There’s no quicker way to become frustrated with the hobby than buying a complicated detector you don’t understand.

All metal detectors detect metal - just like all cars drive down the road. What makes one detector better than another (like cars) is the additional features and enhancements.

Look for a beginner detector in the $150-300 range. Anything below that isn’t really considered a detector - it’s considered a toy.
Budget

This may be the biggest factor of them all, especially when you’ve never tried a metal detector.

Not everyone has $800 to drop on a hobby they aren’t sure they’ll even like.

Most new hobbyists tend to spend $150-$300 on their first detector. Luckily, that buys just enough machine to get you hooked.

Best Entry Level Metal Detectors

Rank

Detector

My Rating

Price

Fisher F22

5/5

Garrett ACE 300

4.5/5

Tesoro Silver uMax

5/5

Don’t worry if you can’t afford a high-end Minelab right away; get an intro model and go find some stuff.


Fisher F22​

Pros

  • Weatherproof
  • Iron Audio
  • Fast Recovery (Processing) Speed
  • Digital Target ID
  • Lighter, easier to use
  • 5 Year Warranty

Cons

  • No adjustable ground balance

See our full F22 review here.


Garrett ACE 300

Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Digital Target ID
  • Adjustable Frequency
  • Enhanced Iron Resolution

Cons

  • No adjustable ground balance
  • No Iron Audio

See our full ACE 300 review here.


Tesoro Silver uMax

Pros

  • Basic and easy to use
  • Very lightweight
  • Lifetime warranty

Cons

  • No adjustable ground balance
  • No Digital Target ID

Intended Use

The type of hunting you plan on doing makes a major difference in what machine you buy.

While most machines are designed as all around detectors for coin, jewelry, and relics, there are also specialty machines for different uses.

Coin and jewelry

Most machines are designed for coin and jewelry hunting - especially those priced under $600 or so.

One thing you want to make sure of here is that you do not buy a machine with too high frequency - i.e., one designed for gold prospecting (you can read our guide here on the best metal detectors for gold nuggets).

As long as you stay under 15 kHz, you’ll be just fine. Frequency and depth have an inverse relationship, so the higher you get, the less depth you’ll get on coin-sized targets.

You’ll also want to avoid a pulse induction machine - or PI for short. These are built more for salt water hunting and gold prospecting.

For all purpose coin and jewelry hunting, stick to a single frequency VLF detector when first starting out.

Read more here about the best metal detector for coins.​

Relic Hunting

The same rules apply for relic hunting. Most all round machines will do just fine for relic hunting.

If however, you’re looking for a more advanced relic hunting machine, you’ll want to look for
features like these:

  • Large coil - preferably DD
  • Slightly higher frequency (10-20 kHz)
  • Adjustable threshold
  • Iron Audio
  • Both manual and auto ground balance

Best Relic Hunting Metal Detectors

Rank

Detector

My Rating

Price

Fisher F75 LTD

4.8/5

Teknetics T2

4.7/5

XP DEUS

4.9/5

You should also take a look at all the Minelab FBS machines (Safari, E-trac, CTX).


Fisher F75 LTD

Pros

  • More coil options
  • 65 tone ID's vs the T2's 6
  • Static all-metal mode
  • Boost mode for enhanced sensitivity and depth
  • Cache mode for deep, large objects

Cons

  • Price

Teknetics T2 Classic

Pros

  • Low price for such a powerful detector
  • Large LCD screen
  • Expanded iron range
  • Can also be used for basic gold prospecting

Cons

  • No backlight
  • DD coils only
  • Does not save settings when turned off

XP DEUS​

Pros

  • Completely wireless
  • Modular setup
  • Can pair with XP pinpointer
  • Ability to change frequencies (4, 8, 12 or 18 kHz) using stock coil
  • Optional HF coils can set freq. up to 81 kHz - great for tiny relics and gold prospecting

Cons

  • Small TID screen

Salt Water Beach Hunting

If you plan to do most of your hunting in and around salt water, you’ll need a specialty machine.

Note that you do NOT need a specialty machine if you’re hunting on the dry sand of a salt water beach.

If hunting in the wet sand, surf or water, you’ll need a machine that’s either PI or multi-frequency.

Do NOT buy a single frequency machine for salt water - despite the marketing material of the company!

Will they work? Sure. But you’re depth will be severely limited to the point where it’s not even worth it to detect.

While either PI or multi-frequency will work, there are some pros and cons to each.

See our complete guide on beach metal detectors here.​

Pulse Induction

Pulse induction machines are not designed to discriminate. So if you plan to hunt beaches where there’s lots of trash, go with a multi-frequency.

PI machines also tend to be a bit heavier since many are built for diving. So you’ll also want to buy something like a chest/shoulder harness to bear the weight.

The major benefit to PI machines is their superior depth in highly mineralized areas like salt water beaches. You just can’t beat it.

Most serious beach hunters use pulse induction.

When choosing any detector for the beach, it goes without saying that you want a machine that’s fully waterproof and submersible - which most detectors are not.

All you need is to be hit by one wave while digging your hole, and the machine is toast if it’s not waterproof.

Best Waterproof PI Metal Detectors

Rank

Detector

My Rating

Price

Tesoro Sand Shark

4.8/5

Fisher CZ-21

4.9/5

Garrett Sea Hunter

4.5/5


​Tesoro Sand Shark

Pros

  • Cheapest PI detector
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Superior battery life

Cons

  • Heavy
  • Can’t change coil or headphones (unless you send to factory)

Fisher CZ-21

Pros

  • Fast response time
  • Audio boost mode
  • Pinpoint button
  • Easy to hip mount
  • Clear tone on deep, faint signals

Cons

  • No threshold adjustment
  • Concentric coil

Garrett Sea Hunter​

Pros

  • Interchangeable coils and headphones
  • Has large 10x14 accessory coil
  • Independently sealed battery compartment
  • Pulse Delay for heavy iron beaches

Cons

  • No volume control

Multiple Frequency

The benefit to using a multi-frequency detector in salt water is that you can discriminate out unwanted targets.

You can also use the same machine for all of your hunting as opposed to the PI where you should only really use it for beach hunting.

The only real con to using a multi-frequency machine on the beach is that you won’t get the type of depth you would with a PI - although it will still be excellent.

Best Waterproof Multi-frequency Metal Detectors

Rank

Detector

My Rating

Price

Minelab Excalibur II

4.6/5

Minelab CTX 3030

5/5


Minelab Excalibur II

Pros

  • Excellent iron discrimination
  • Multi-frequency machine that can also be used for diving
  • Very accurate tone ID
  • Submersible to 200 ft

Cons

  • Iron null delay can make you miss good targets
  • Hardwired headphones
  • Requires additional kit to hip mount
  • No tone on deep, faint signals. Just threshold change.

Minelab CTX 3030​

Pros

  • Superior discrimination and target ID
  • Don’t need to buy separate land machine
  • Lots of coils available
  • LCD display
  • Digital Target ID

Cons

  • Price
  • Can't be used for diving

Fresh Water Hunting

Freshwater hunting is a MUCH easier beast to tackle.

The only factors you need to consider here is that you get a fully submersible machine with good discrimination - that’s really it.

Best Fresh Water Metal Detector

Rank

Detector

My Rating

Price

Garrett AT Pro

5/5

Garrett AT Gold

4.9/5

Fisher 1280x

5/5


Garrett AT Pro

Pros

  • Fully waterproof and submersible to 10 ft
  • Manual and auto ground balance
  • Proportional audio
  • Iron audio

Cons

  • Waterproof headphones sold separately

Garrett AT Gold

Pros

  • Can also be used for gold prospecting
  • Better ground balance options than AT Pro
  • “True All Metal” mode
  • Smaller coil for moving between rocks

Cons

  • Pro audio only. No standard option like AT Pro
  • Waterproof headphones sold separately

Fisher 1280x​

Pros

  • Fully submersible to 250 ft
  • Volume control
  • 75+ hours battery life
  • Low 2.4 kHz freq. which is great for coins

Cons

  • No LCD display
  • Not ideal for relic hunting or gold prospecting

Gold nugget hunting (prospecting)

Prospecting machines can range from $500 all the way up to $10,000.

Most of these machines will be PI and should be used in areas where gold is known to be found.

If you want the best gold prospecting detector, go with a Minelab. They can’t be beaten.

​Click here to read our complete guide on the best metal detectors for gold.

Best Metal Detector for Kids

What is the best kids metal detector? All the same rules above still apply, the only real difference, is going to be weight.

Depending on how old the child is, you might want to start with a detector that’s not super heavy.

You may also want to get a machine that’s relatively easy to use with not a lot of settings. Stick to the basics.

Best Metal Detectors for Kids

Rank

Detector

My Rating

Price

Fisher F22

5/5

Garrett ACE 300

4.5/5

Tesoro Silver uMax

5/5

Click here to read my in-depth guide to choosing the best metal detector for kids.


Fisher F22

Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Fastest processing speed
  • Weatherproof
  • 5 Year warranty

Cons

  • Slightly higher learning curve

Garrett ACE 300

Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Often available with free accessories

Cons

  • 2 year warranty
  • Not weatherproof

Tesoro Silver uMax​

Pros

  • Easy to use, only two knobs
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Super lightweight

Cons

  • No LCD screen

Technology

There are a few different technologies you should familiarize yourself with when choosing which detector to buy.

I will summarize each below very broadly:

Very Low Frequency (VLF)

Very low frequency (VLF) is the technology built into most detectors - pretty much any machine under $1,000.

These are signal frequency machines used for coin, jewelry, and relic hunting. If you’re just starting out, get yourself a VLF.

Pulse Induction (PI)

Pulse induction (PI) is a technology used in specialty machines for areas of high mineralization - i.e., salt water beaches and gold country.

These machines will punch through ground minerals like salt and iron and will report on all metal objects without the ability to discriminate.

Multiple Frequency (MF)

Multi-frequency (MF) detectors are typically machines that go for over $1,000 and most commonly found in the high-end Minelab detectors.

These are best if you’re serious about detecting and have the budget to back it up.

They’re also great for doing both saltwater and all around detecting without having to buy two machines.

I use the Minelab CTX 3030 for this very reason.


Search Coils

Another thing to consider is the stock coil that comes with your detector. There are a few points you should consider when choosing a coil.

Stock coil size

Generally speaking, the larger the coil, the better the depth.

So common sense tells you to buy the largest coil, right?

Wrong.

There are other factors to consider. First, ground conditions and mineralization play a huge role in which size coil to use.

While large coils get better depth, they also see more of the ground which means your detector has to process more signals in mineralized soil which can lead to very bad falsing, poor target ID and missed targets.

When that happens, you’re forced to reduce your sensitivity, and thus reducing your depth.

A smaller coil would see less of the ground, process less ground signals and allow you to increase your sensitivity to the point where you could be getting the same depth as you would with the larger coil in neutral ground.

Make sense so far? Ok, let's confuse this further now…

Not only would a smaller coil give you comparable depth in mineralized ground, but it would also give you better target separation so you can better identify multiple targets under your coil (picking up good targets amongst trash).

And speaking of target separation, let’s talk about coil configuration.

Stock coil type

There are several types of coil configurations - the most widely used being the concentric and the double d (DD).

Without getting into too much detail, DD coils will get you better detection depth and deal with ground mineralization better than a concentric.

Concentric coils are typically more cost-effective. The only real advantage it has over the DD (in my opinion) is that it can be easier to pinpoint your target. Pinpointing with a DD coil just takes more practice.

Accessory Coil Sizes

Ground mineralization aside, there are a few other reasons why you might want to have additional coil sizes in your bag.

If you’re hunting small, tight areas like playgrounds or very rocky areas like in gold country, then you should consider a smaller coil for better maneuverability. These coils are called sniper coils.

Alternatively, if you’re looking to cover large, open areas like beaches and farm fields, a larger coil might be a better option.

Just remember, larger coils will be a lot heavier so you may need to get some type of harness if you want to detect more than 30 minutes.


Screen vs. no screen

Most experienced hunters detect largely by sound, but a screen (VDI) comes in handy.

It can tell us things like depth of the target, what it thinks the target is, where our sensitivity and discrimination are set, battery life and many other things, depending on the detector.

Some folks think it’s silly to own a machine without a screen, while others are just fine with a Tesoro-type detector that features only knobs.

The Fisher F5 integrated both of those worlds. It has a screen and knobs. For those who like the best of both worlds, that may be a detector worth looking into.

Metal detectors without a screen are commonly referred to as beep and dig machines since there’s no display telling you what the detector thinks it has found in the ground.


Detector Weight

Some metal detectors are light as a feather while others are built like bricks and can be quite heavy.

If you have elbow or shoulder problems or another ailment that limits physical activity, it’s recommended to get a lighter detector.

Fisher and Tesoro have reputations of being the lightest in the industry. Mid and high-level machines like the AT Pro are quite a bit heavier but still not a monster.

When considering your first machine, pay close attention to how much it weighs, especially if you plan on hunting for several hours at a time.


YouTube is your friend

Once you have narrowed your choices down to two or three detectors, watch them in action on YouTube.

There is nothing like seeing them and hearing the owners talk about them to give us a great idea what the machine is like and how it works.

YouTube features everything from reviews to testing to actual hunting scenarios, and everything in between.


Read reviews

This one may sound obvious, but you’d be surprised how many people purchase a detector ‘completely blind’, so to speak, having never read a single review on the machine.

So, if you are thinking of the Fisher F22, for example, type Fisher F22 reviews into your search engine and read as many as you can find. They truly do help.

You can also find my in-depth review of the Fisher F22 by clicking here.​

Whether watching youtube videos or reading online reviews, take everything with a grain of salt.

Don’t let a negative review affect your buying decision. Most negative reviews are a result of someone buying the wrong detector.

Remember, the ‘right’ detector depends on factors like skill, budget, use, location, etc.

A perfect example of this is when people say the AT Pro is awesome in salt water.

Look at where they’re located. Are they near the Gulf of Mexico where salt levels aren’t as extreme as the Atlantic and Pacific oceans?

They almost always are.

Another example is when people try to use an entry level detector in areas like the pacific northwest where the soil is extremely mineralized.

It’s not that the detector is bad, it’s just the wrong application.


Quality Brands

I typically recommend you stick to the known brands for their quality and customer support.

Those brands are:

  • Fisher
  • Garrett
  • Makro
  • Minelab
  • Teknetics
  • Tesoro
  • XP
  • Whites

Warranties

You should also understand how the warranty works for the brand you decide.

Most brands will have a warranty ranging 2-5 years except for Tesoro which is lifetime.

If you’re buying a water machine, the warranty is usually much less (1-2 years).

Also if you decide to buy used, make sure the warranty is transferrable as some brands do not allow this.


Accessories Included

Finally, you might also want to consider any accessories that might come with your detector - especially if you’re trying to stay on budget.

If you’re new to the hobby, some accessories you’re going to find yourself buying at some point are:

  • Pinpointer
  • Headphones
  • Digger
  • Pouch
  • Carry bag
  • Scoop (if beach hunting)

Don’t be fooled by some retailers who include cheap accessories with their detectors - especially with pinpointers and diggers.

Usually, these items are about the same quality as you’d find in the dollar store - despite the retailer claiming “hundreds of dollars in value!”


Wrapping Up

Metal detecting is a hobby you can grow into overtime. There’s no need to buy the most expensive detector right away and have no idea what you’re doing.

Don’t overthink your first purchase. This article talks about a lot of factors to consider, but it’s not intended to scare you away from your first purchase.

As long as you stick to your price point with one of the major brands, you really can’t go wrong.

I hope this guide was helpful and that you now have a better idea of the best metal detector for YOU!

Good luck and happy hunting.

Summary
Mark Orwig
 

My name is Mark Orwig and I am obsessed with keeping my mind busy, keeping active, and staying healthy.

93
Leave a Reply

48 Comment threads
45 Thread replies
2 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
48 Comment authors
  Subscribe  
Notify of
John t

What a load of rubbish!! In reading this article it’s obvious you know nothing about the best metal detectors what a joke the Garrett at pro best metal detector 😂😂😂 the at pro has very limited depth on coins and other nonferrous Targets you haven’t even mentioned the best detector which is the minelab etrac by a country mile

Yuniarta

Very helpfull tips….thanks Jason….

Atahuallpa Mejia

Hello Mark, which Metal detector would you say is good all around, water proof, depth, dry/wet sand, all metals, relics, gold, silver nuggets, etc
A Metal Detector that i can use to find everything on water and land.
Many thanks

Andy

Great article thanks.

I’m new to this so I’m after entry level. Do you have an opinion on the F22 DD? Is it worth extra orshould I stick with the F22?

Kevin

Great article. I was curious if a low end Garrett would be good for detecting underground pipes and water lines. I know there are other method for doing so, but I’m in an odd situation with the possibility finding an underground bunker.

Don Kepple

Mark,

Interested in starting to metal detect. Good article and great information. Was wondering what to get for my area. Currently in southern Tennessee, silt and clay loam down to about 31 inches deep. Budget can be as high as $1000. Would like to search for what I can find but probably relics or the like. Lots of old land to search around here. Any help or guidance is greatly appreciated.

Don Kepple

Paul

Hi Mark thanks for very informative selection criteria. I am looking for Gold flakes/small nuggets in a very mineralized iron ore area and quartz veins also to search in shallow streams. Budget from $600 – $1600 . Kindly advise several unit options in your order of preference.
many thanks

Peter Johnston

Mark: Your explanations and examples were very helpful, but I cannot decide between a VLF or PI system. I need a detector to find a Samsung smartphone that I lost in the woods. I rented a detector, but the head was 8″ in diameter and it picked up on the mineralization. I got a lot of false-positives, and didn’t find my phone. Would I need a PI head to deal with the heavily minerlised soils in the search area? My lack of experience is evident. Given my comments above, would you kindly recommend the type of machine that would give… Read more »

Barbara

Thank you for the professional and insightful article, Mark!! I am starting this hobby at 50 years old! As a retired teacher, I found your information, tips, and expertise extremely valuable! I also like the honest reviews and set up of your post. Thank you and happy hunting!!

D. Melz

Hi Mark, Awesome site and I hope you can assist me! I am looking for my first metal detector. My family and I live in Bucks County, Pa (just outside Philly and about 1/2 hour south of Princeton). The area has a rich history, including Washington crossing the Delaware to fight in the battle of Trenton. Of course, most of the land is privately owned and finding areas to detect could be an issue. However, the local parks do allow for some detecting with permission. There is also some olf and abandoned railroads, creeks where covered bridges once existed. I… Read more »

Leo Drescher

Mark: I have been hunting for 50 yrs and have always updated my
White’s detectors about every 5yrs. I have the v31 now. I love these machines I have thought about updating again and am about to purchase the Etrac. This after detecting with club members and comparing results.
Thanks for your information.

Todd

Hi Mark, My family and I live in southern Arizona. We have tossed around the idea of buying a metal detector to take with us when we go out four wheeling. We like remote areas and typically try to find old mine sites (gold, silver, copper). So we are looking at steep, rocky slopes which can have high levels of iron and quartz. Would like to do some prospecting, but would also like to find artifacts. So, with that in mind, what would you suggest as the best all around detector for us. Would like to keep it under $1000… Read more »

Jeffrey Arias

Thank you so much for the article. Would you consider The Garrett GTI2500 to be an out-dated machine? Any thoughts? I am stuck between the Fisher 75 Special edition, GTI2500 and the AT MAX.

Yves

Very informative article. Right now I’m in the market for a all around detector with a 500$ budget. As for location it will be mostly in the Canadian sheild in heavy woods, around swamps and lakes and rivers and there is lots of rocks and boulders. It is also very rich in minerals and granite. The rest of the time will be spent in fields with sand and bleu clay. What would you recommend

anthony fermicola

1 just retired and I want to get into metal detecting. I was going to get the new whites treasure probe, but I see they just came out with mx7. supposed to be mxpro bot down priced . but it goes deeper than the treasure pro. what is your opinion?

Milo

Hi Mark, Thank you very much for the very comprehensive and detailed article. this certainly helped me. I was looking to buy an ace 250 but then realised that it won’t work for me. I live in Cape Town and will use my device for beach hunting but I also have a love for History, and will also go to different fields and historical places around South Africa, (whenever I get a chance). Based on your article I would have loved the CTX 3030, but seeing as that is just a tad over my budget, I’m thinking of rather going… Read more »

Tony Sley

Hi Mark, I have been saving for a few years to buy the right metal detector however they have been getting more bells and whistles as the years go on and now I’m unsure which is right for me. Even though I travel around a lot, and my hunting conditions are always changing, jewelry and coins are my top targets… then relics and so on. What I would like to find is a detector that did it all (beaches, rivers, mountains, divable, ect.) but I’m not sure if that exists. Do I need multiple detectors? Or can I get away… Read more »

Mikki

Hi Mark,

I have to agree with everyone, your article was extremely helpful! I am thinking of buying my 1st metal detector and am still a little confused over which would work best for the area I would like to search. I love by a dry riverbed and am interested in looking for relics as well as small pieces of gold. I believe the area is also high in other minerals. Is there a detector that would allow me to search for these items at a reasonable cost for a beginner?